Powered by over 170,000 consumer panelists, InfoScout’s real-time read on Thanksgiving Day and Black Friday sales indicates that early reports of a strong holiday shopping season for America’s major retailers may be inflated.
With consumer electronics dominating the list of best sellers at Walmart, Target, Best Buy and even Kohl’s, these retailers now find themselves exposed to the deflationary pressures of the gadget industry. Last year, consumers were exposed to exciting new products, and shoppers swarmed in to seize the new must-haves like the iPad Air, Beats Headphones, PlayStation 4, and Xbox One. As an industry that relies on innovation, the relative lack thereof in 2014 has left American shoppers unwilling to spend more for only minimally improved versions of their favorite products. With their top-selling items now on-shelf at reduced prices, retailers will need to sell many more units than last year to keep pace with sales from the 2013 holiday season.
The list of best selling products in each of Walmart’s top holiday categories is remarkably unchanged, with slightly better offerings at predominantly lower prices.
Target carries a similar assortment of products to Walmart and therefore faces similar deflationary headwinds this holiday season. Sales of iPads had accounted for such a large percentage of Target’s holiday sales in 2013, that the retailer will have to steer shoppers towards other products in 2014 in order to overcome the large year-over-year price reductions.
Even the highly innovative Amazon has struggled to improve upon its Kindle Fire offering from last year. In fact, consumers are trading down this year from 7-inch to a 6-inch display at a much lower price point.
It should be no surprise then that average basket values appear to be down across almost every major retailer compared to the year prior. Early data coming in from InfoScout’s panelists’ shopping in stores on Black Thursday & Black Friday indicate that only Macy’s has managed even the slightest gain in their average transaction. While this data is just a preliminary read, it is derived from more than 42,000 shopping trips reported thus far at the retailers below.
To stay on top of America’s shopper journey throughout this retail holiday season, be sure to subscribe (above) for real-time updates.
(Author’s note: Special thanks to Ben Ahn & Bret Weinberg for their real-time reporting.)